Authenticity 50 Bed Sheets and Bedding Reviews

Reviews

The Highest-Rated bedding available, accept no substitutes.
4,000+ 5-star Reviews including hundreds of Google Customer Reviews. 

"We tested 31 different sets... Authenticity 50 are the Best Overall Value"
GEAR PATROL

Hear what our customers say in the Reviews below!

Based on 3820 reviews
92%
(3512)
4%
(155)
2%
(68)
1%
(37)
1%
(48)
C
Custom Comfort Pillows
Cindy A. (Palmdale, California)
Pillow review

One of the best purchases I have made with regards to bedding. Very happy with my pillows and plan to order another set.

B
Custom Comfort Pillows
Base (Cranberry Township, Pennsylvania)
Nap Time

Best pillow I ever owned!! So glad I finally ordered them! Even my picky hubby loves his new pillow. Ordered 2 pillows! AND made in USA!!

T
Custom Comfort Pillows
Trudy S. (Sacramento, California)
Pillows

My pillows are fantastic!
My daughter is the one that recommended them.
I'm extremely happy with my pillows.

Trudy

l
Heritage American Sheets
loraine p. (Walnut Creek, California)
Great bedding!

Nice to find a quality fabric for bedding. I always try for American cotton and it's great to find American made.

Heaviest, most well made blanket I’ve ever purchased.

B
Custom Comfort Pillows
Brandon R. (Waller, Texas)
The difference is amazing

A friend bought this pillow for me as a house warming gift. I fell in love the first night. My spouse tried to sleep with it and I said, “this is the only thing I have in the house, it is mine!” Both of us were waking up with neck aches, and back aches. I have a great night sleep without the aches. My spouse used it one night and slept though the night waking up refreshed and happy (that is rare). We are now buying my spouse their own pillow.

C
A50 Flat Sheets
CCobb (Lake Helen, Florida)
Sheets like Mama had

These cotton sheets feel and smell like the ones my mother used to put on our beds. I have been searching for great sheets, and found them here! Thank you.

These sheets are so so comfy! The cotton is cooling. I have two sets and 2 of their heritage blankets . Let’s not forget the pillows I bought as well! I can’t say enough good about this company. Made in the USA. If I could only get my hands on the towels when they are back in stock!🤗I have the wash clothes and hand towels as well. I simply love the products!!!!

K
Heritage Blankets
Kay V. (Neenah, Wisconsin)
Blanket

Even though we haven’t used the blanket yet as the temperatures don’t require it, it looks very well made and it looks like a nice size and love the color.

C
Custom Comfort Pillows
ChrisP (Blue Springs, Missouri)
LOVE LOVE LOVE

Fell in love with my pillow the first night! So comfy and neck ache is gone!

C
Custom Comfort Pillows
Carolyn S. (Dedham, Massachusetts)
Standard pillow

The pillow is too thick for my taste but it is going in my guest room. There is a definite chemical odor which I am hoping will dissipate as I just opened the package. I also thought I was getting 2 pillows for $100 but there is only one. The picture of 2 pillows in the cart is deceiving so be aware. Lastly but most annoying is that the cover had 2 dirty creases and spots at one end. The packaging was not damaged or opened prior to arrival which means that the pillow was rolled and packaged dirty. I love my blankets and used to have sheets which I loved. (I had to donate the sheets when I got a deeper mattress.) I’m disappointed in the pillow and won’t be ordering any more pillows.

Hi Carolyn,
Thank you for taking the time to leave a review for our Custom Comfort Pillows. We are sorry to hear that the pillow was not to your liking and that there was a chemical odor upon opening.
We would like to assure you that the odor should dissipate with time and use. Additionally, we apologize for the misunderstanding regarding the number of pillows included.
We do want to mention that the fill in our pillows can be removed to adjust the loft to your preference.
Regarding the packaging, we apologize for the dirty creases and spots. Our customer support team will take care of this for you.
We value your feedback and appreciate your loyalty to our brand. Please do not hesitate to reach out to us for any further assistance.
Thank you for choosing our products.
Best,
Customer Service Team

J
Custom Comfort Pillows
Jane S. (Wayland, Massachusetts)
Excellent products!

So very happy with my Authenticity50 sheets and pillows; they are comfortable, so well made, and I especially appreciate that they are products of the US. It is my second purchase from Authenticity50 and won't be my last.

J
A50 Fitted Sheets
JAC (Providence, Rhode Island)
Wonderful

Purchased first set and am very pleased with quality and feel. Will be ordering more!

D
Heritage Blankets
Dolores R. (Seattle, Washington)
Heritage Queen blue blanket

I like the blanket's weave, weight, & quality... top notch 😉😊

P
Heritage Blankets
Penny B. (Myrtle Beach, South Carolina)
Lightweight and Warm

I was looking for blanket that wasn't heavy, but keeps me warm. After a long search, I found it inthis blanket. It's of good quality. The bonus is It's made in the USA.

S
Custom Comfort Pillows
S.S. (Aptos, California)
Strong smell

I really want to like this product and support the company - but even after several days it smells like I am at an oil refinery. I don’t know if it the cover, the filler, or both. Will try washing the cover next.

Help!

Dear valued customer,

We are sorry to hear about your experience with our Custom Comfort Pillows. This is not normal and we apologize for the inconvenience it has caused you. Please do not hesitate to reach out to our customer service team. We are dedicated to providing the best experience for our customers and we would be more than happy to assist you. Thank you for your support and understanding.

These pillows have the perfect weight, amount of fill, and with the soft cover, make them as excellent pillow for all kinds of sleepers.

K
Envelope Closure Pillowcases
Kathleen R. (Nashua, New Hampshire)
The Best!

The sheets and blankets I purchased from Authentically 50 are top quality. They wash beautifully and look great. I was thrilled to find a company committed to American manufacturing.

J
Heritage Blankets
James D. (Miami, Florida)
Love the blanket

Didn’t get the discount when I waited for color I wanted, other than that , the blanket is cool

Best sheets I’ve bought EVER!!!!! I want more colors please!!!!!

Amazing quality I will always buy sheets and any products from Authenticity50 well worth it is an understatement!!!!

So nice. Feels like I'm in a high end hotel

A
Heritage American Sheets
Al R. (Boardman, Oregon)
Great Sheets

Our fourth purchase: sheet set. Authenticity 50 doesn’t disappoint. Great quality and I like “American Made”.

G
Envelope Closure Pillowcases
Gram (Atlanta, Georgia)
Envelope Closure Pillowcases (Heritage)

Loved the sheets so much I ordered a second set, then wanted a couple of extra pillowcases. They are great! Very well made and have a very comfortable feel.

R
Custom Comfort Pillows
Ralph W. (Centerton, Arkansas)
Best sleep

Amazing pillow. Best one I’ve ever purchased. Extremely comfortable

sleep icon

100 Night Sleep Trial

Order without worry. You can return your order at no cost within the first 100 nights.

shipping box icon

Free & Fast Shipping

Your order will ship same day or next business day. You can expect it to arrive in 2-3 days. See details HERE.

chat icon

U.S. Customer Service

If you can't find the answer in our extensive FAQ you can reach our support team by clicking HERE.

cotton icon

Carbon Neutral Shipping

Your order is shipped with the environment in mind. We've removed 10,000 lbs of emissions just in the last 2 years.

Customer Reviews

Based on 438 reviews
95%
(415)
3%
(11)
1%
(6)
0%
(1)
1%
(5)
D
Deb

Heaviest, most well made blanket I’ve ever purchased.

K
Kay V. (Neenah, Wisconsin)
Blanket

Even though we haven’t used the blanket yet as the temperatures don’t require it, it looks very well made and it looks like a nice size and love the color.

D
Dolores R. (Seattle, Washington)
Heritage Queen blue blanket

I like the blanket's weave, weight, & quality... top notch 😉😊

P
Penny B. (Myrtle Beach, South Carolina)
Lightweight and Warm

I was looking for blanket that wasn't heavy, but keeps me warm. After a long search, I found it inthis blanket. It's of good quality. The bonus is It's made in the USA.

J
James D. (Miami, Florida)
Love the blanket

Didn’t get the discount when I waited for color I wanted, other than that , the blanket is cool