Custom Comfort Pillows

"When we decided to open the Welcome Inn to guests, I knew we needed the most comfortable beds possible. I tried plenty of pillows and finally landed on Authenticity50’s Custom Comfort pillows. I use these at home and they have changed the way I sleep forever!" -Jenny Marrs (HGTV's Fixer to Fabulous)

Sale price$ 109.00
Size: Standard

Size

In stock

HGTV Fixer to Fabulous Star Jenny Marrs' Favorite Pillow...soon to be your favorite pillow!

Do you wake up with a sore back or neck in the morning? Want a more comfortable and cooler-sleeping pillow but not sure where to start? Our pillow is completely adjustable, so you can get the perfect fill for you! A zippered side gusset allows you to remove or add fill to exactly the fill level that is right for you. Like a flat pillow - take fill out; like a full pillow - leave the filling in. 

You'll sleep better knowing your pillow is 100% Seed-to-Stitch® Made in USA by the best manufacturers in America. We start with clean CertiPUR-US® foam with cooling properties rather than cheap scrap foam. We then source amazing knit fabric from the best knitters in South and North Carolina. And the pillows are sewn, by hand, in California for a truly hand-made product. Save 10% when you purchase a bundle!

 

"When we decided to open the Welcome Inn to guests, I knew we needed the most comfortable beds possible. I tried plenty of pillows and finally landed on Authenticity50’s Custom Comfort pillows. I use these at home and they have changed the way I sleep forever!"
"From the cotton to the weaving of the fabric, to the final cut and sew - all of it done here."
Sleepers can add or remove the cooling gel memory foam and microfiber blend to ensure the level is not too full, not too flat, but just right.

Forget high, mid, or low loft...

This pillow's got YOUR back (& neck)

Everyone hates their pillow and we set out to solve that. Rather than offering different options for side, back or front sleepers we created a pillow that YOU can customize to exactly your sleep style. Want less loft - take some fill out; want more loft - add some in. This way you can make sure the pillow has exactly the right amount of loft for you.

To give your head and neck the cushiony support it needs we use a special blend of clean CertiPUR-US certified shredded gel memory foam and microfiber. Most cheap pillows use whatever scrap foam they have left over from manufacturing. The cooling cover is also machine washable - so it can be refreshed to like-new comfort.

  • 5 stars: 672 (93%)
  • 4 stars: 34 (5%)
  • 3 stars: 5 (1%)
  • 2 stars: 7 (1%)
  • 1 star: 8 (1%)
R
Randy G. (Pottstown, Pennsylvania)
Firm and comfy

The pillow is very comfortable and gives your neck some support
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED

M
Meg D. (South Portland, Maine)
Best.Sleep.Ever.

I’m extremely picky about the pillows that I sleep on. As a side sleeper, I need to have the right height and comfort and these pillows easily meet both of those criteria. The quality is there. After sleeping on them for over three weeks and making adjustments to the fill, I’m sleeping like a baby. My first time using pillows with adjustable fill so was a bit hesitant to take some out as the height of the pillows was a bit too high. I took four handfuls out (I have tiny hands)of one to try it out and it was perfect once I made the adjustments which was extremely easy to do and took under five minutes to adjust both. They now fit like a glove and remind me of the luxury pillows that I have slept on in high-end hotels. I will be making recommendations to friends and family. So glad that I found this company in my Google search. I’ll be checking out the blankets and sheets come Spring. Photo of the two pillows with the extra fill in the ziploc bags. I’ll hang on to it for awhile, just in case.

J
Jared D.
Highest quality sheets I’ve owned.

Love the crisp feel, although I had to wash them once before they were really bed worthy.

M
Monica M.
Best pillows EVER!

Best pillows you will EVER buy! I have both the standard & king size of these pillows, love them both although the standard is now my favorite. I will never buy any other brand of pillow ever again because Authenticity pillows are supportive, comfortable, don’t get hot, keep their shape & hold up for several, several years. Definitely a quality product that I will continue buying!!

D
Dawn
Standard pillows

I have to say I was skeptical as buying new pillows has always been difficult let alone buying made in the USA!!! Thank you Authenticity50 for the best pillow that have ever tried. I get the best nights sleep with your pillows. Quality is excellent 5 star in my opinion. Will definitely share with friends and family.

Thank you
Dawn Corolla

M
Michael L.
Hands down, my favorite pillow of all time.

Most comfortable pillows I have ever used. Easy to fluff in drier and stay fluffed longer than past pillows I have owned. It brought a smile to my face when I laid eyes on that Made in USA tag. It's hard to find a pillow made in USA 100%, but your search is over! My neck pain has gone away after sleeping with this pillow every night and I hope A50 will continue to sell this pillow. You owe it to yourself to have a comfy pillow that you look forward to laying on every night like I do. GET IT!!!

J
Janice S.
Best pillows!!

These pillows are just the right amount of support. And I love the soft cover. Be sure you put in dryer for few minutes when you get them like instructions say. They smell out of package but dryer will solve that. I love them and searched for ones made in USA. THEY ARE MUCH better than My Pillow brand.

S
Sally M.A.
Great pillows!

I gave our two 30 year old adult children pillows for Christmas. They wondered why then, but now they won’t use anything else! They really sleep better and I just ordered two pillows for me snd my husband.

B
Brandy B.
The Unicorn of pillows!

The perfect pillow is impossible to find! Too soft, too firm, not big enough... The Custom Comfort Pillow is the unicorn of pillows!! The fact that you can add or remove the memory foam filling makes it the BEST pillow on the market! It is dreamy & fabulous! I ordered the king size and absolutely LOVE it!! And let’s be honest, the fact that it is Made in the USA is the cherry on the sundae!! Highly recommend!

R
Rebecca B.
Great Pillows!

I bought 4 pillows for my family of 4 to replace our old sad flat pillows. They are VERY THICK. It was a transition from my flat pillow. I am a side sleeper and it turns out the support is exactly what I need for this position. I think they are adjustable so I imagine no matter what kind of sleeper you can get just the right fit. No complaints from my husband or kids, 8 and 10.

M
Monica M.
Best pillows ever!

I have chronic neck issues & these are the best pillows I’ve ever owned. I’ve never had a better night’s sleep. Totally with the money & is a quality product that I will continue to buy

M
Michael B. (Saugerties, New York)
Nice Pillows!

I really like the quality of these pillows, they are so well made, this is evident as soon as you unpack them. Very comfortable to sleep on. Very happy with this purchase.

T
Tara B.
My favorite pillow!

Just ordered two more so I have extra for guests!

M
Mary

Finally a supportive pillow that’s adjustable and very comfortable! My only minor issue is that the standard size is a little too big for Queen size pillow cases. Very happy with these pillows being completely made in the USA!

J
Janet A. (Worcester, Massachusetts)
Great pillow!

I’ve only used the pillow for a week, but so far I love it! We recently upgraded from a queen to a king bed, so I needed a king sized pillow. I am very pleased with the quality.

b
blaine s. (San Jose, California)
Large FIrm pillow. I'm happy with mine!

More a Queen Size than a standard if you choose to NOT REMOVE ANY OF FOAM FILLER. I Like it the thick Queen size but it fits the King Size Authenticity50 better than their Standard size pillowcase. Better a few inches too long than a few too short with pillow end poking out.

I'm quite happy with it using the Authenticity 50 king pc. I like that it's a little larger and thicker, won't be removing any of the filling to make it smaller.

I've been looking for a quality pillow for a while and am very pleased with this one. Well worth the $$
5 stars

N
Neil S. (Laguna Niguel, California)
My 3rd Purchase

What I love about this pillow 1). It comes with a ton of stuffing - you can remove as much as you want so the pillow is as thin or thick as you like. 2). It's made in U.S.A. which is great plus there is no chemical smell like many pillows you get from overseas 3). It's really comfy with a thick, quilted outer shell.

N
Nancy P. (Youngstown, Ohio)
Custom comfort pillow

Initially, my interest was that all products from Authenticity 50 were made in the United States. My first purchase was a custom comfort pillow for myself. I am a side sleeper and was experiencing neck pain that I felt was a result of poor alignment by the pillow I was using. So I purchased a pillow and was able to adjust the loft that kept my neck in a better alignment. This alleviated my pain. I loved the pillow so much that I purchased one for my son and daughter, and they have loved their custom comfort pillow as well. I look forward to trying their sheets next.

J
Judith L. (Louisville, Kentucky)
Perfect Pillow!

Love this pillow! Supportive yet soft and pliable! Supports side sleepers so well.

L
Les (Kansas City, Missouri)
Best pillow ever

I have struggled for years trying to find a comfortable pillow. Either no support or severe neck pain. I happened on Authenticity and it really has changed my sleep for the better. Every night I get into bed, my head touches my pillow and I think to myself, I love this pillow.
My Fitbit for the first time ever is notifying me each morning that I have had a great nights sleep and high score readiness for the day.

T
Teresa L. (Grand Rapids, Michigan)
Two king size pillows

I have had less severe neck pain since these pillows arrived.
It is amazing how well made and the company stays in touch from the point of ordering.

L
Lisa (New Braunfels, Texas)
Pillow

Very comfortable nice pillows

j
jack g. (Rochester, Minnesota)
Pillows

Love them stay cool all night! Neck is happy also!

A
AS (Fresno, California)
The best pillows!

We only use these pillows and also love giving them as gifts.

J
Jan S. (Stillwater, Oklahoma)
Custom Comfort Pillows

When Jenny Marrs showed these pillows on Fixer to Fabulous and talked about their comfort, I was curious.
So I looked at the Authenticity 50 website and was impressed with their
100% Seed-to-Stitch® Made in USA pillows because I prefer to buy made in USA products. I really like that the filling is adjustable and the cover is washable. The pillows I bought two years ago are as fresh and full as the ones I bought 2 months ago. No flattening at all. I’ve given some to family members and we all agree they are the most comfortable pillows ever! No more neck pain for anyone!

S
Susi B. (Houston, Texas)
These pillows!

I've tried several different kinds of pillows, but so many of them were "a pain in the neck". These are supportive and have kept their loft for a very long time now. These are definitely my go-to pillows.

Manufacturing aligned with YOUR values

Made in USA from Seed-to-Stitch®

We’re proud to support skilled workers, their families, and communities from coast to coast with our local manufacturing process. These American-made pillows are crafted across the country - the outer covers are knit from organic cotton and polyester in South Carolina, and cut, sewn, and filled with premium US-foam at a world-class facility in Southern California. Leaders in green manufacturing, this family-owned and operated factory goes to lengths to lower their carbon footprint and use sustainable materials.

You’ll be proud to own and use these pillows every night. They’re super comfortable pillows that are 100% Made in USA from Seed-to-Stitch®.

Ethics aligned with YOUR values

Imports are a dirty business - we're cleaning it up.

7,000

Miles traveled by their products

300

Miles traveled by ours

Higher standards for quality, worker safety, and environmental impact

When you purchase your Custom Comfort Pillows, you'll be supporting a family-owned facility with a commitment to sustainability and ethical labor practices. By choosing American-made you not only invest in a higher quality product, but also the health of the planet, the local economy, the well-being of workers and your purchase uses ZERO smog-coughing container ships.

You can rest easy knowing our Custom Comfort Pillows traveled just a few hundred miles during their manufacturing process compared to thousands of miles with other brands. And we use CertiPur-US foam in our pillows specifically because it is not only made in the USA but it is made without ozone depleters, without PBDEs, TDCPP or TCEP (“Tris”) flame retardants, does not contain mercury, lead, and other heavy metals, is manufactured without formaldehyde and without phthalates. While most other pillows are filled with scrap foam - we invest in only the best foam!

Smoggy international container ship polluting waters

NASTY IMPORT POLLUTION

authenticity50 founder at loom in georgia

CLEAN U.S. MANUFACTURING

Drag
Carbon-neutral shipping on all orders
21540kg
shipping emissions removed
That's like...
55142
miles driven by an average gasoline-powered car

FAQ

Do you hate dealing with overseas customer service? We do too! Our local support team is US-based and ready to assist you.
Contact Us
Authenticity50 co-founders Steph & Jimmy touring a manufacturing facility.

We're Jimmy & Steph

Everyone told us it’s impossible to make textiles here in America. We didn’t listen and launched Authenticity50 via Kickstarter in 2015. 

In business for over ten years, we’re proud to be the first company dedicated to bringing back American-made bedding and bath products. We’ve even expanded our collection to include cotton sheets, blankets, pillows, duvets, and towels - 100% Seed-to-Stitch® Made in the USA!

We hope you'll join us in our mission to support American workers and make the best products here, at home.

Read more about us

We're Jimmy & Steph

Everyone told us it’s impossible to make textiles here in America. We didn’t listen and launched Authenticity50 via Kickstarter in 2015. 

In business for over ten years, we’re proud to be the first company dedicated to bringing back American-made bedding and bath products. We’ve even expanded our collection to include cotton sheets, blankets, pillows, duvets, and towels - 100% Seed-to-Stitch® Made in the USA!

We hope you'll join us in our mission to support American workers and make the best products here, at home.

Read more about us

Authenticity50 co-founders Steph & Jimmy touring a manufacturing facility.