Custom Comfort Pillows

146 reviews

Size

Finally back in stock and shipping!

  • Customizable.. for you.

    Want a more comfortable pillow but not sure where to start? Our pillow is adjustable so you can get the perfect fill for you! A zippered side gusset allows you to remove or add fill to exactly the fill level that is right for you. Like a flat pillow - take fill out; like a full pillow - leave the filling in. And you'll sleep better knowing your pillow is 100% Seed-to-Stitch® Made in USA by the best manufacturers in America. Purchase a set of 2 and save 15%.

    • Exterior: A cool sleeping polyester case with side gussets.
    • Interior: A stretchy inner liner allows the cover to be easily removed for washing.
    • Fill: Our proprietary shredded memory foam and microfiber blend is made especially for us with foam made for pillows - not scraps. Cooler sleeping and more comfortable than traditional pillows.
  • Size Dimensions
    Standard 20 x 28
    King 20 x 36
    Width x Length x Depth in inches

Our Guarantees

free shipping

Free Shipping and Returns

Order without worry. Cost of shipping is on us. And returns are free within 100 days.

sleep trial

100 Night Sleep Trial

We love our products and we think you will, too. If you’re unhappy with your purchase within 100 nights, we’ll cover the cost of return and issue a full refund.

seed to stitch american made

100% Made in the USA

Our entire manufacturing process—from fiber, to fabric, to final product—supports over 500 local jobs. Learn more about our partners HERE.

Customizable Comfort

cooling pillows

A pillow perfect for you.

Finding a great pillow shouldn't be a challenge. Side Sleeper? Back Sleeper? Down or molded foam? We've taken the guessing out of your pillow search. Our Custom Comfort Pillow is adjustable so you can get just the right loft for you. The side gusset allows you to change the amount of foam stuffing - and wash the cover when you want to freshen up your pillow.


cool sleeping pillow
Cool sleeping

Comfort cover

adjustable fill
The perfect fill

Customizable comfort

washable cover
Keeping you clean

Washable cover

down free alternative
Cruelty-free

No ducks were harmed

Better fill - better sleep.

We use a special blend of shredded gel memory foam and microfiber to give your head and neck the cushiony support it needs - without the heat. Now you can have your pillow extra fluffy and your partner can take out the fill for the flat feel they love.

shredded memory foam pillows

cooling pillow

A pillow perfect for you

Finding a great pillow shouldn't be a challenge. Side Sleeper? Back Sleeper? Down or molded foam? We've taken the guessing out of your pillow search. Our Custom Comfort Pillow is adjustable so you can get just the right loft for you. The side gusset allows you to change the amount of foam stuffing - and wash the cover when you want to freshen up your pillow.


cool sleeping pillow
Cool sleeping

Comfort cover

adjustable fill pillow
Perfect fill

Customizable comfort

washable cover
Keeping you clean

Washable cover

down alternative pillow
Cruelty-free

No ducks were harmed

shredded memory foam pillows

Better fill - better sleep.

We use a special blend of shredded gel memory foam and microfiber to give your head and neck the cushiony support it needs - without the heat. Now you can have your pillow extra fluffy and your partner can take out the fill for the flat feel they love.

Frequently Asked Questions

Free Domestic Shipping

We take care of our customers and include free ground shipping for orders to the lower 48 states. We use USPS, Fedex and UPS depending on delivery location. Orders are shipped within 1 business day and expedited shipping options are available at checkout.

Why did you make your pillow adjustable?

Everyone is unique when it comes to the way they sleep and their preferences. Some like a lot of loft - others want a flatter feel. With our pillows you can get the fill just the way you like it - your neck will thank you. :)

What if I need more fill than what comes in the pillow?

We try to fill our pillow to a level that is comfortable for most people. But if you need more fill just reach out to us at customerservice@authenticity50.com and we'll send you extra fill - no charge.

Can I wash my pillow?

You can remove the inner liner and wash the outer cover when necessary. Once or twice a year is enough for most people. And the pillows pair beautifully with our Envelope Closure Pillowcases.  


gear patrol

This Near-Perfect Pillow

Custom Comfort Pillows

"We found a pillow that’s as soft or as firm as you need. Authenticity50, the American-made seed-to-stitch bedding company, just restocked its Custom Comfort Pillows, which have sold out like clockwork since their 2019 release."

cooling memory foam pillows made in usa
made in usa bedding

We're proud to support hard working men, women and their families and communities from coast to coast. The knit cover fabric is made in the Southern States. And the pillows are cut, sewn and filled at an amazing facility in California.


cooling pillows
american made

We're proud to support hard working men, women and their families and communities from coast to coast. The knit cover fabric is made in the Southern States. And the pillows are cut, sewn and filled at an amazing facility in California.

american made manufacturing
made in usa pillows

Shop these favorites

Envelope Closure Pillowcases

Signature Sheets