What’s the Best Cotton for Bed Sheets?

What’s the Best Cotton for Bed Sheets?

Updated October 2022

You're probably confused about what matters most when buying bedding. All the experts contradict each other and it's hard to get a straight answer from anyone. We encountered the same issue when we decided to launch our own bedding brand, Authenticity50, so we went straight to the source and spoke with the MANUFACTURERS about what really works. These include the manufacturers of high end hotel bedding and towels as well as farmers, yarn spinners, weavers and finishers.

touring cotton farms in america

Touring an American cotton farm

First things first, everyone agrees that cotton is the best material for great sleeping sheets. It's the best blend of cool hand, dry feel, durability and washability. 

But not all cottons are created equally, and some of them are downright BAD. So how do you tell the difference, and which ones should you be scouring the internet for?

Here are the top three choices in cotton sheets:

Supima Cotton

Supima cotton is grown in the US in California and Arizona.  Because it’s grown right here in the US, there are strict standards for it to make sure it’s worthy of one of the best cotton labels in the biz.

Supima cotton is top shelf, the best cotton you can buy:

  • Less than  3% of the cotton grown in the USA can be called Supima®
  • Supima® cotton has  45% stronger fibers than other cotton fibers
  • Supima® costs more than 2x the price of regular cotton (because it’s the BEST)

The combination of the perfect percale weave and thread count makes these sheets not only durable, but smooth, soft, and easy to fall asleep on. 

Shop Cotton Sheets

American-grown Cotton

If you source your cotton from high quality American growers you can find some of the best cotton in the world. It's mostly naturally irrigated by rain fall and, unlike some cottons grown overseas, always picked by machine rather than hand. In addition you're supporting local business and communities as well as better working conditions than overseas cotton. 

At Authenticity50 we know our yarn spinners and can make sure we're getting the highest quality cotton from their farmer's crops. This assures us a great quality at a fair price. While we used Supima for many years, and still do, the price increase of 3x over the space of two years made it incredibly expensive relative to the quality so many brands are adjusting. 

helicopter cotton tour

Touring a cotton field by helicopter

view of cotton tractor from helicopter

View of the cotton harvester from helicopter 


 

Pima Cotton

We like Pima cotton because it’s typically grown in the US, and is of a good quality. It’s smooth, cool, and makes for some REALLY luxe sheets — if you’re getting the real thing.

Again, the issue we run into with  Pima cotton is similar to the problems with Egyptian cotton: you really never know if you’re getting the real deal, or an overpriced knockoff.

If you’re getting Pima cotton sheets that are from a reputable source grown here in the US, you can bet that the quality will be pretty good. But there’s no way to verify it, and ultimately,  you’re only going to know when you actually start sleeping on those sheets.

The Best Cotton Sheets EVER

We love, make, and sell American-grown cotton sheets because we like to sleep well, too. Cotton is the best fabric to go with, and American-grown cotton is at the top of the cotton category for sheets and the best value for your money.

It’s smooth, it’s silky, it’s insanely soft and breathable, and it’s the only type of cotton that has a quality verification process, so you KNOW you’re actually getting what you’re paying for.

But don’t take our word for it — we have a 100-night sleep trial.

Shop Authenticity 50 Sheets

Supima Cotton

Pros:

Verified authentic by the Supima® Association

Makes insanely soft and cool sheets

Grown ONLY in  America

Consistent quality

The softest and most durable cotton available

Cons:

More expensive than Egyptian cotton


American-grown Cotton

Pros:

Very soft and durable

Smoother than cheaper cottons

Good quality and fair pricing

Cons:

To get the best you need relationships with manufacturers

Quality varies from batch to batch so relationships are important

High demand can increase prices

Can be more expensive than imported cotton


Pima Cotton

Pros:

Very soft and durable

Smoother than cheaper sheets

Generally good quality and often grown in USA

Cons:

May be grown abroad

Not monitored by 3rd party organizations

Not as smooth as Supima cotton

May be blended with cheaper cotton


 

PS: What about Egyptian Cotton? 

Egyptian cotton used to be the standard for excellence in the cotton industry,  but recent reports show that most Egyptian cotton is  fake.

According to an article in the  Wall Street Journal, "The Cotton Egypt Association, which licenses the trademark and certifies suppliers, estimates that 90% of products labeled “Egyptian cotton” are fakes but such public rebukes for mislabeling are rare."

So the real deal? Authentic Egyptian cotton is nice, with quality that rivals Supima cotton — but  there’s no way to verify if you’re getting the real thing, or an expensive knockoff.

Our advice? Steer clear of Egyptian cotton until the industry finds a way to verify it.

 

 

Made in USA Bed sheets

 

Reading next

Manufacturer Series - The finest sheets start with the world's best cotton

16 comments

Sheila

Sheila

I have 100%Ima cotton sheets. They wrinkle very badly
I dont like to iron
When I do just do along the top edge but the wrinkles never go away even with steam.

Daniel Richards

Daniel Richards

Doesn’t the Cotton Egypt Association now verify that the procuts with there stamp on are verified Egyptian cotton now? Seems a new recent verification company that make sure all cotton is 100% Egyptian

Joan Marie Gebhardt

Joan Marie Gebhardt

Why do my new Supima 100% cotton sheets feel stiff and like plastic when they are wet?

Authenticity 50

Authenticity 50

Hi Martha, Jenny,

Thanks for your questions! We definitely recommend our Authenticity 50 Signature Series Sheets which get great reviews! In regards to the Pima cotton being itchy it is most likely due to the chemical treatments they use to make the sheets wrinkle free. These can irritate people’s skin and is the reason we minimize/eliminate heavy chemical treatments.

Martha Morrison

Martha Morrison

I brought Pima cotton sheets. After washing them they made me iitch all night!! Has anyone else had the itching problem?? They are not smooth to the touch. Microfiber sheet do me the same way so I am thinking they maybe a blend and not 100percent cotton. I hate Pima cotton!!!

Leave a comment

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

sleep icon

100 Night Sleep Trial

Order without worry. You can return your order at no cost within the first 100 nights.

shipping box icon

Free & Fast Shipping

All orders ship next business day. Further details HERE.

chat icon

U.S. Based Customer Service

If you can't find the answer in our extensive FAQ you can reach our support team by clicking HERE.

cotton icon

Carbon Neutral Shipping

Every order is shipped with the environment in mind. We've removed 10,000 lbs of emissions in the last 2 years.